
On Saturday, November 7, federal Judge Tiffany M. Cartwright ordered the release of Baljit Singh, an asylum seeker from India held at the ICE processing center in Tacoma, Washington. No contested hearing. No government arguments. No one on the other side of the bench. The habeas corpus petition reached the court and the government simply did not show up. The judge put it in writing: the petition stood as “intentionally unopposed.”
It was not a one-day oversight. It was the first visible consequence of a letter that the acting U.S. Attorney for Western Washington, Charles Neil Floyd, sent to the district’s chief judge on October 26. In two pages, Floyd tells the court something no prosecutor wants to put in writing: his office no longer has the lawyers to defend every ICE detention.
The letter that changed everything
Floyd does not mince words. He writes that his office “does not have the available resources, at this juncture, to continue entering AUSA appearances in every one of the dozens of § 2241 Immigration Petitions filed each week.” And he goes on: “Thus, going forward, in order to conserve resources, there will be many habeas cases in which the USAO will no longer assume responsibility for providing a defense on behalf of the respondents.”
The mechanism is simple, and that is what makes it so powerful. When the court issues its scheduling order in a habeas corpus case — the petition a detainee uses to ask a judge to review whether his detention is lawful — a seven-court-day clock starts running. If no prosecutor files a notice of appearance within those seven days, the court may assume no government response is coming and decide the case on the detainee’s papers alone.
The letter adds two more things. In the cases the office does not defend, it will neither move the case forward nor serve as a bridge between the court and ICE: release orders may be emailed straight to the Tacoma detention center. And the office reserves the right to appear in any case, whenever it sees fit. In other words: it is not walking away from everything, it is picking its battles.
Floyd says the change will streamline and speed up most petitions and give the court more discretion. He also lists what each appearance costs his office: status reports, supplemental briefing, fee motions under the Equal Access to Justice Act, and show-cause orders over what he calls “often technical violations” of the scheduling order.
The first person freed: detained in September after ending up at the Canadian border
Singh had been released under supervision while his asylum claim was pending. In September, ICE detained him after he and some friends visiting Peace Arch Historical State Park ended up at the exit to the Canadian border. He filed his habeas corpus petition last month. The government never answered.
The government’s answer was not due until November 12. Cartwright did not wait: she ordered his release five days early and gave the government one day to comply. Singh walked out on Monday, November 9, and the court entered final judgment in his favor the same day.
The judge wrote that she knew of no precedent for the Justice Department declining to appear on behalf of a federal agency instead of filing a statement of non-opposition. Even so, she accepted the letter as the department’s official position. And Singh is not the only one: at least one other petition in Western Washington has already been granted unopposed since the letter arrived, according to court records cited by Raw Story.
Careful: this is not automatic release
The government staying away does not mean the door swings open on its own. The judge still has to find that the detention is unlawful, and an unanswered petition is not a default judgment. Without the government’s brief, the judge reviews the record on her own and looks for gaps. The petitions best placed to win are the ones built on issues this district has already decided many times — for example, the right to a bond hearing for long-time residents who entered without inspection, or the re-detention of people already under supervision.
Anyone filing a petition without a lawyer is more exposed. Many detainees in Tacoma file handwritten petitions, and law students at Seattle University have begun helping some of them under attorney supervision, according to KING 5.
Floyd’s office, for its part, will keep reviewing every petition and every scheduling order, forward them to ICE, and appear “as the USAO determines appropriate.” The signal for whether the government will fight a case will now be whether its lawyer shows up on the docket.
The numbers behind the collapse
Western Washington had more than 1,400 active habeas corpus cases last month, according to the independent tracker habeasdockets.org, cited by KING 5. About 2,000 have been filed since January 2025. Dozens every week. And the problem is not just Seattle’s: border czar Tom Homan said last week on Fox News that courts are carrying about 85,000 immigration habeas cases nationwide, while ICE holds more than 65,000 people in detention.
Behind the backlog there is another number: more than 10,000 federal lawyers have left the government since the start of 2025, and the Justice Department has shed 21% of its attorneys, according to Above the Law. The detention machine grew faster than its own ability to defend it in court — while ICE operates with a target of 2,700 arrests a day.
And there is a detail almost no one mentions: Floyd himself was one of the judges who, along with three other Washington judges, advocated barring immigration courts from granting bond to detainees. That question — whether a detainee has the right to a bond hearing — is now before the Supreme Court. The same week the Homeland Security chief said Congress could open a path to residence for DACA recipients, with no amnesty.
Colorado went through this already, and left a warning
Washington is the second district this fall to let government silence decide habeas corpus cases. The first was Colorado, where prosecutors and the court signed a formal agreement on October 8: if the government does not answer within seven days, the detainee must be released within 24 hours.
There, the weak link was the handoff between the court and ICE officers. One release order took nearly a week to reach the responsible supervisor. In other cases, ICE added GPS monitoring — headquarters policy, according to one official — and a supervisor testified to a directive to re-arrest some people freed on judges’ orders.
On Monday, November 9, Nathan Rasper, acting head of ICE’s Denver field office, testified before Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney that he himself gave the verbal instruction to re-arrest people released on judges’ orders, that he had not known about the court’s agreement when he did, and that the practice has stopped. Judge Nina Y. Wang gave the government until Tuesday to produce ICE’s directives on release conditions. Other Colorado judges are already writing orders that limit re-arrest — in one case, only on a final removal order; in another, with advance notice to the court.
Washington is different: there is no agreement with the court here, just a one-sided letter, and release is not automatic. The judge decides each case. But the handoff risk is the same, and now with no prosecutor in the middle to check that the order arrived. Another federal judge last week ordered New York to hand ICE the names of Bronx shelter residents — the courts remain the ground where, day by day, the limits of detention are decided.
What to watch if a relative is detained in Tacoma
If someone in your family is detained at the Tacoma center, or has a habeas corpus petition pending in Western Washington, there are three things lawyers are watching now. First, the docket: if no government lawyer appears within seven court days of the scheduling order, the judge may decide on the petition alone. Second, the petition has to stand on its own — without the government’s brief, the judge will look for gaps — so it is worth having a lawyer review it before filing. And third, ask for the release terms in writing: no conditions beyond the prior supervision, and no re-detention by ICE without notice to the court or a hearing.
This article is not a substitute for an immigration lawyer. But the change is real, and it already has a first freed detainee with a name. And what happens in Washington — and in Colorado — could repeat in other overloaded districts: two offices have already let silence speak for the government. We will see how many follow the example.
Official sources
- Associated Press — “Faced with influx, prosecutor in Washington says he lacks resources to defend immigration cases” (November 9, 2026)
- Simple Justice — text of Acting U.S. Attorney Charles Neil Floyd’s letter to Chief Judge David Estudillo (October 26, 2026)
- Immigration Analytics — “Seattle Prosecutors Stop Defending Many ICE Habeas Cases” (November 9, 2026)
- Above the Law — “Trump’s DOJ Ran Off So Many Lawyers It Can’t Even Show Up To Keep People Locked Up Anymore” (November 10, 2026)




Comentarios