
Twelve names.
That is, for now, what ICE says it has in its sights inside the Bruckner shelter in the South Bronx. Twelve men who, according to the agency, listed that address as home and face charges for serious crimes. A federal judge ordered on Friday that the City of New York hand over their information. Not everyone’s. Just theirs. And with a filter in between: a court-appointed official will review the files before ICE sees a single name.
The 12-page order was signed by Judge Lewis A. Kaplan of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, in the case United States v. City of New York (No. 25-mc-559). It ends — for now — a fight of more than a year between the federal government and the city over the data of people sleeping in its shelters. And it leaves a mark that reaches beyond the Bronx: a federal judge has just said that sanctuary-city laws are not enough to stop a federal subpoena once a court orders compliance.
Exactly what the judge ordered
The city must comply with an ICE administrative subpoena from October 6, 2025, which asked for the full name and date of birth of every man housed at the Bruckner shelter, at 825 East 141st Street in Mott Haven, plus any records that would help identify them.
But ICE will not receive the full list. At a hearing in March, the government agreed to limit itself to residents with records for eight serious offenses: murder, manslaughter, rape, robbery, assault, grand larceny, burglary, and assault of a law enforcement officer. A special master appointed by the court will review the files and pass ICE only those names.
The judge gave the parties 14 days to submit a joint proposal on who that special master will be and how the position will be paid. That puts the next step around November 20.
Kaplan was blunt in his reasoning: “The City has not shown that producing this list would be unduly burdensome.” And he added that, with the special-master filter, the court “has no choice but to compel the subpoena’s enforcement.”
One thing to be clear about: the order does not order anyone arrested or deported. It requires the city to help identify certain residents. Whatever happens with those names afterward is another step, and another process.
Four subpoenas in fourteen months
The fight did not start on Friday. It started in August 2025, when ICE asked for the data of every man in two city-run shelters. The city refused and called the request an improper fishing expedition, lacking any legitimate investigative purpose.
ICE withdrew that subpoena and on August 22 filed a narrower one, only about Bruckner and only about noncitizens with records for the eight offenses. The city refused again: it said the request would still force it to conduct a long, costly investigation on ICE’s behalf. On September 5 came an amended version through the U.S. Attorney’s Office. That was not enough either. And on October 6, the subpoena that ended up in court: the names and birth dates of every man at the shelter.
The government took the case to court with two sworn statements from a Homeland Security Investigations agent. According to those documents, the agency knew of about 100 people receiving their immigration mail at the shelter, of at least 20 who had entered the country without authorization and listed that address as their residence, and of 12 who also faced charges for one of the eight offenses.
The city argued that ICE was using the subpoena to get around its sanctuary-city laws and that the motive was more political than investigative. The judge did not buy it: that suspicion, he wrote, has no support in the record. He also rejected the fishing-expedition idea: the subpoena targets a shelter known to house migrants, and ICE agreed to limit what it receives.
The Bruckner shelter: 2,200 beds and a closing date
The Bruckner is a converted warehouse in the South Bronx, with room for about 2,200 people. It opened in 2025, when the city moved asylum seekers there from Randall’s Island. Today it is the city’s last emergency migrant shelter still standing.
And its days are numbered for another reason: Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced in February that the shelter will close before the end of the year and that its residents will move into the general homeless shelter system. The judge’s order does not change that plan. But it does change what happens with the data of the people living there in the meantime.
What this means if you live in a shelter
First, what it is not: it is not a mass handover of data. ICE does not walk away with the shelter’s census. It walks away — if the process goes ahead — with the names of men facing charges for serious crimes, after a court official reviews each file. And note: charges, not convictions. The ruling speaks of people accused, not people convicted.
Second, what it is: a precedent. New York fought every one of ICE’s four subpoenas since August 2025, and it lost this one. Other sanctuary cities are watching the ruling, because the argument the city used — that the subpoena sidestepped its local laws — did not hold up before the judge. The federal government, on top of that, has already sued the city to strike down those laws. That is another battle, still open.
Third, the practical part, and this does not change with any ruling: if you live in a shelter, or know someone who does, keep your documents in one place and have an immigration lawyer’s number at hand. Do not open the door without a judicial warrant signed by a judge, do not sign anything you do not understand, and stay silent until you speak with a lawyer. And if anyone charges you to “get you off the list” at the shelter, it is a scam: there is no such list you can pay to leave.
What comes next
On Monday, Mamdani said his administration is studying the order and its legal options. State Attorney General Letitia James is also reviewing whether an appeal is possible. The New York Immigration Coalition, which brings together more than 200 organizations, has already asked the city to appeal.
The calendar, meanwhile, keeps running: the parties have 14 days to propose the special master. And the shelter, with its closure planned for the end of the year, will stay at the center of the fight until the last day.
The White House, for its part, shows no sign of easing up: ICE’s target is now 2,700 arrests a day, and the president said this week his policy has not changed. On the other side, Democrats arrive in Congress in January promising to investigate ICE, and the Homeland Security secretary has opened the door to talking about a path to permanent residence for DACA Dreamers. This ruling is the first round of that fight in the courts. It will not be the last.
Official sources
- U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, Memorandum Opinion and Order, United States v. City of New York, No. 25-mc-559 (Nov. 6, 2026): https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.654411/gov.uscourts.nysd.654411.49.0_1.pdf
- EFE (via ABC Color), “Un juez ordena a Nueva York informar a ICE sobre los residentes de un albergue en el Bronx” (Nov. 9, 2026): https://www.abc.com.py/internacionales/2026/11/09/un-juez-ordena-a-nueva-york-informar-a-ice-sobre-los-residentes-de-un-albergue-en-el-bronx/
- La Tribuna Hispana, “Un juez federal obliga a NYC entregar información de inmigrantes” (Nov. 10, 2026): https://www.latribunahispana.com/2026/11/un-juez-federal-obliga-a-nyc-entregar-informacion-de-inmigrantes/
- El País, “El ICE no frena sus redadas mientras los demócratas preparan su ofensiva contra la agencia migratoria desde el Congreso” (Nov. 10, 2026): https://elpais.com/us/migracion/2026-11-10/el-ice-no-frena-sus-redadas-mientras-los-democratas-preparan-su-ofensiva-contra-la-agencia-migratoria-desde-el-congreso.html




Comentarios