
“You’ve got a remedy, for goodness sake. Go out and indict.”
That was how federal Judge David Carter answered the Justice Department’s lawyer on Tuesday, without mincing words. They were in Los Angeles, at a hearing that took up an entire afternoon — and that could decide whether California counts thousands of mail ballots a week before the November 3 elections.
What the government was asking sounded simple on paper. That California set aside the mail ballots of more than 20,000 registered voters the government flags as possible noncitizens, and not count them until it verified that the person who voted was a citizen. In the courtroom, Carter did not see it as simple. He said setting those ballots aside would be a “monumental change” to the rules of an election already under way, and he worried about disenfranchising — and confusing — legitimate voters.
The judge did not rule on Tuesday. He promised to do it this Wednesday. That leaves California, a week out from the election, waiting for a decision that could land at any point in the day.
What the Justice Department asked for
The lawsuit arrived on October 15, in federal court in Los Angeles. According to Reuters, it was the first time the Trump administration sought to prevent a state from counting votes. The government’s argument is that California did not do enough about a list of more than 20,000 names that, according to its databases, belong to people who might not be citizens.
Justice Department lawyer Bilal Essayli argued on Tuesday that the request was narrow: only to safeguard the integrity of the election. Carter answered with the line that sums up the hearing. If someone voted without the right to do so, he said, the traditional remedy is to indict them criminally. And unlawfully cast ballots, he added, can be removed in the weeks after Election Day, before the official results are certified. In his logic, there is no need to halt the count now.
There is one fact the government did not give at the hearing, and it is worth holding onto: the Justice Department did not say how many of those more than 20,000 people had actually sent in a mail ballot. Being on the list is a government flag, not a finding that someone voted illegally.
How California answered
Anne Bellows, a lawyer for the state, said the federal claims rested on “mysterious database methods” and that complying risked disenfranchising eligible voters. Her other argument was about timing, and it carries weight in court: the Supreme Court, she recalled, has said again and again that federal courts should not change the rules when an election is close at hand. “This applies with even more force when the election is ongoing,” she said.
California also maintains that its safeguards against noncitizen voting are robust. And there is a precedent that landed a day earlier in the same fight: on Monday, the Ninth Circuit rejected 2-1 the Justice Department’s attempt to bypass Carter and block the count directly on appeal. The court called it premature. Judge Gabriel Sanchez, in his concurring opinion, wrote that the government was asking a federal court to dictate to a state legislature a matter “squarely within the state’s traditional domain,” upending its policies and inviting “disorder and confusion for voters and election officials alike.”
If you already read on this site how the list of 20,000 names reached California and the 48 hours the government gave it, this hearing is the next chapter: the case went back to the judge who was supposed to decide it from the start. And if you follow the other leg of the same case, the Ninth Circuit had already left the count standing on Monday, and Washington received a list of 400 names the same day.
Carter’s other message: stop the threats
In the middle of the legal argument, Carter left another message, aimed at the government’s lawyers: “This court believes that it would be wise that any threats to state and county election employees cease immediately.” It came from a concrete fact: on October 16, the Justice Department warned California election officials they could face criminal liability if they counted ballots from flagged voters.
That climate is not abstract for anyone working an election. Voting-rights advocates cited by Reuters have warned that federal methods for scrubbing state voter lists risk wrongly flagging naturalized citizens. A Reuters investigation published in July found just 129 cases in which noncitizens were federally charged with voting illegally; many, according to that investigation, appeared to stem from confusion or administrative errors, not organized fraud.
What a California voter should do
First, the basics, which this hearing does not change: only United States citizens may vote in federal elections. A permanent resident, no matter how many years they have lived in the country, cannot vote for president or for Congress. That is not in dispute in this case.
Second, if you already voted by mail in California, do not assume you are on the list or that your ballot has been set aside. The government has not said how many flagged people sent in a ballot, and counting continues while Carter has not ruled. Check your ballot status on California’s official tracker — and keep any notice you receive from your county.
And third: the ruling comes this Wednesday. If Carter grants the order, California would have to set those ballots aside until citizenship is verified. If he denies it, the count continues as it has, and the government would still have the criminal route, case by case. Either way, what is decided in Los Angeles will be read across the country: it is the same tug-of-war — federal lists, state counting, an election already under way — that already reached Washington with 400 names.
Official sources
Reuters, “Judge skeptical of Justice Dept lawsuit over alleged noncitizens on voting rolls” (Luc Cohen and Jan Wolfe, October 27, 2026): https://wixx.com/2026/10/27/us-judge-to-weigh-justice-depts-effort-to-block-california-from-counting-alleged-noncitizen-votes/
Reuters, “Trump administration loses push to block California votes from alleged noncitizens” (October 27, 2026): https://www.devdiscourse.com/article/international/3997675-trump-administration-loses-push-to-block-california-votes-from-allegednoncitizens?amp
Vote.gov, voter registration and verification (official U.S. government site): https://vote.gov




Comentarios