
“Asking a federal court to dictate to a state legislature a matter squarely within the state’s traditional domain.” With that line, Judge Gabriel Sanchez summed up why two Ninth Circuit judges did not want to step in — at least not like this, and not this fast — in California’s vote count.
It was 2-1. And it was this Monday, October 26, eight days before the November 3 elections.
The Justice Department wanted something very specific: that California separate the mail ballots of people on a federal list of more than 20,000 registered voters — people the government says are likely not citizens — and not count them until each person’s citizenship was verified. The San Francisco-based appeals court denied that emergency request.
Note this carefully: the majority did not say whether the government is right or wrong on the merits. It said something narrower, and more important for understanding the day: that the Department had not given the trial judge an adequate opportunity to consider the case first, so it was premature for the appeals court to weigh in. The trial judge has a hearing scheduled for this Tuesday.
The majority was made up of Judge Mark Bennett, appointed by Trump, and Judge Gabriel Sanchez, appointed by Biden. Judge Patrick Bumatay, also appointed by Trump, dissented.
The lawsuit was filed on October 15 in federal court in Los Angeles. According to Reuters, it is the first time the federal government has tried to stop a state from counting votes. And there is a detail the government itself has not clarified: it has not said how many of those 20,000 people have actually submitted a mail ballot in this election.
What is known about the list is another figure, given by Department officials on October 19: 28 people have been criminally charged with voting illegally.
California, for its part, did not stay quiet. In an October 20 filing, lawyers for Secretary of State Shirley Weber said the Department’s claims rest on “suspect data” and called the litigation, at best, “a reckless political stunt” — and, at worst, a threat to disenfranchise thousands of Californians in this election.
One fact helps put the list in perspective. Los Angeles County staff reviewed a sample of 200 records from that list. What did they find? Canceled or inactive registrations, people with no voting history, and voters who appeared to have been born in the United States.
The fine print does not support the idea of massive fraud, either. A Reuters investigation published in July found just 129 cases in which noncitizens were federally charged with voting illegally; many appeared to stem from confusion or administrative errors, not intentional fraud.
And the context is broader than California. The Department has warned election officials in all 50 states that they could face criminal prosecution if they knowingly allow noncitizens to remain on the rolls or vote, and it has sued 30 states and Washington, DC, for refusing to hand over complete voter rolls including voters’ sensitive personal data. So far, according to Reuters, it has lost 26 of those cases without winning one.
Meanwhile, in Washington
That same Monday, the Department knocked on another door. It asked Washington state to set aside any ballots it receives from more than 400 people it suspects registered without U.S. citizenship.
In a letter to the Secretary of State’s office, the Department said it had identified 1,500 votes cast by those more than 400 people in prior elections, and asked that their midterm ballots be set aside until the state confirms they are legally eligible voters. Washington has more than 5 million registered voters.
“We are asking the state to set aside those ballots until we can confirm they are legal voters,” Acting U.S. Attorney Neil Floyd said at a news conference.
Washington Secretary of State Steve Hobbs was reviewing the demand. His office noted it has received about 60 subpoenas from the Justice Department since last month seeking voter information. “We take our responsibility to protect voter information seriously and will only respond to requests that follow due process,” Hobbs said in an emailed statement. “We see what’s happening in California and don’t want Washingtonians to be harassed.”
The Department itself acknowledged two nuances worth keeping in mind: it expects to send the state another list of suspected people before Election Day, and it noted that some of the people it suspects registered without citizenship may have since become naturalized.
Prior investigations into similar claims, cited in the coverage, also did not turn out as announced: in Nevada, the government alleged 1,500 possible noncitizen voters and the subsequent investigation found zero; in Maricopa County, Arizona, the recorder — a Trump supporter — announced 207 possible noncitizens and the Republican county attorney determined there were actually eight.
What this means, and what it does not
It means, for now, that California does not have to set those ballots aside by order of the appeals court. It does not mean the case is over: Tuesday’s trial-court hearing is still on, and the fight could return to the appeals court.
For anyone who already voted by mail in California, today’s ruling does not change their ballot. For anyone voting on November 3, it does not change where or how to vote.
If you are a naturalized citizen and you worry about appearing on a list like this, the practical step is to check your registration on your state’s official elections portal — Vote.gov will direct you to your state’s — and, if you receive any notice, do not ignore it: contact your county elections office with your proof of citizenship at hand. And remember the basic rule, which does not change here: only U.S. citizens may vote in federal elections.
What happened this Monday was, at bottom, a clash over timing: a government that wanted an order before the votes were counted, and a court that told it to first let the judge who has the case speak. On Tuesday we will learn the next chapter. And on November 3, eight days away, the list is no longer just California’s: now it also has a Washington version, with 400 names and 1,500 old votes behind it.
To follow this dispute, read the piece on the 20,000-name list California refused to use to set ballots aside, the one on this week’s deadlines and the more than 29 million votes already cast, and the one on 28 million early votes and the tie in Texas.
Official sources
- Reuters: Trump administration loses push to block California votes from alleged noncitizens
- SRN News (Reuters republication, 26-oct-2026): Trump administration loses push to block California votes from alleged noncitizens
- The Manila Times: Trump administration asks Washington to set aside ballots of 400 suspected noncitizen voters
- Vote.gov (official portal to check registration and find your state’s elections office)




Comentarios