
Did you get a letter from ICE with a fine you couldn’t pay in ten years?
That’s not an exaggeration. For every day a person under a final removal order stays in the United States without leaving, the government can fine them up to $998. At that rate, a year adds up to more than $364,000. And there are real cases over a million dollars: one of the plaintiffs in the lawsuit against these fines received one of about $1.8 million. Today she is a permanent resident. The fine is still there.
Today, Monday, November 16, is the deadline to file a claim against part of those fines. This is not just any deadline: it is the only window the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) itself opened for people who believe the process used to fine them harmed them. If you got one of these letters, here is what you need to know before the day ends.
The window closes today: what exactly expires
On October 26, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin signed a notice in the Federal Register ratifying all final civil penalties that ICE and Customs and Border Protection (CBP) imposed between June 27, 2025, and October 13, 2026. Ratification, in this context, means the government is saying: these decisions stand, even though the process used to impose them was adopted without the public comment period the law normally requires.
Along with that ratification, DHS opened a 21-day window for people who were fined to say whether that fast-track process caused them concrete harm. That window closes today, November 16.
Claims go by email to IFRCivilFinesReview@ice.dhs.gov. And watch this: DHS requires the email’s subject line to carry the person’s full name, date of birth, and A-number, and the body to include their current address, a phone number, the penalty tracking number, and the invoice number. Without that information, ICE says it will not review the claim.
One thing needs to be clear: this is not an appeal. DHS says so itself. It is a narrow channel to argue that the process — not the fine itself — harmed you. And there is no guarantee of anything: ICE will decide whether harm was shown and what remedy, if any, is appropriate.
Which fines are we talking about, exactly
There are three, and it helps not to mix them up.
The heaviest is for failing to depart after a final removal order: up to $998 for each day of noncompliance. DHS calculates the fine for no more than five years before its decision, so in extreme cases the total passes $1.5 million.
The second is for failing to leave within a voluntary departure period: between $1,992 and $9,970, and in practice usually $3,000, set by the immigration judge.
The third is for entering — or attempting to enter — the country without authorization: $100 to $500 per entry or attempt. That one is imposed by CBP, not ICE.
What makes this program different from any earlier immigration fine is its scale. Between June 27, 2025, and September 14, 2026, ICE imposed about 110,000 failure-to-depart fines and CBP about 66,000 improper-entry fines. Around 176,000 in total. For comparison: under the old process, 12,135 had been imposed in three months. The pace tripled: from about 930 fines a week to nearly 2,800.
And there is another number that says a lot. In July, DHS told Bloomberg Law it had already imposed more than 103,000 fines worth a total of $84 billion. The government itself acknowledges that in some cases the amounts exceed $1 million per person.
Almost nobody appealed: only about 3% of failure-to-depart fines were challenged — 3,072 appeals through September 10, 2026. But of the appeals DHS has already decided, one in four won. That is why today’s deadline matters: there are fines that, on review, do not hold up.
One important nuance: these fines do not fall on just anyone without papers. They target people who already went through immigration court — they hold a final removal order or a granted voluntary departure — and then did not leave. Having an expired visa alone does not trigger the daily fine.
These fines are one more piece of the same enforcement push: in fiscal year 2026, ICE deported 483,200 people, the highest total in its history, and arrests also set a record.
A judge in Boston already froze collection
None of this happens in a legal vacuum. On September 30, federal Judge George A. O’Toole Jr., of the District of Massachusetts, stayed the June 2025 interim rule and all fines issued under it, in the case Maria L. v. Mullin. While that stay remains in effect, DHS cannot collect or enforce the fines from that period.
But the stay has a limit worth not misunderstanding. It does not cover fines dated October 14, 2026, or later, because those are already imposed under the final rule, published that day in the Federal Register. If your notice is dated October 14 or later, the stay does not protect you: the deadline to appeal is 15 business days from when DHS mailed the letter — service counts from the mailing date, not the day you receive it.
The fight went on. On November 6, the plaintiffs filed two emergency motions arguing that DHS violated the judge’s order by publishing the final rule and ratifying the fines. The case is still pending, and the ratification does not lift the stay: a fine from the covered period can be both suspended from collection and ratified for the future at the same time.
What to do today, in order
Government letters come with dates that do not forgive: just like the Social Security letter warning that your Medicare ends February 1, this one also expires today. Here is what to do, in order:
- Find the date on your notice. It is the first thing that decides everything else: if the fine is from June 27, 2025, to October 13, 2026, it falls in today’s window; if it is from October 14 onward, the 15-business-day appeal deadline applies.
- If your fine is from the first period and you believe the fast-track process harmed you — for example, you could not present your case or did not find out in time — write today to IFRCivilFinesReview@ice.dhs.gov with all the information DHS requires: full name, date of birth, and A-number in the subject line; address, phone number, penalty tracking number, and invoice number in the body.
- If your fine is from October 14 or later, count 15 business days from the mailing date shown on the letter, not from when it reached you. That is your appeal deadline, and the final rule only accepts late appeals if you can show the mail was delayed for reasons beyond your control.
- If you are considering leaving the country on your own, do it through the CBP Home app. DHS has said it will cancel most of these fines for people who arrange their departure through that channel.
- Talk to an immigration lawyer before paying anything or signing anything. This article is general information, not legal advice: every case — final order, voluntary departure, pending appeal — plays out differently.
What comes next
The Boston lawsuit is not settled: the stay is preliminary and can be narrowed, broadened, or lifted as the case moves forward. The October 26 ratification does not change the amount of any fine either, nor does it revive fines already reversed on appeal.
Meanwhile, the rules are shifting on the streets too: in Houston, police will no longer call ICE at a traffic stop unless there is an arrest for an offense that carries jail time. Two different fronts of the same enforcement push, and it pays to know both.
What does change today is the chance to file a claim. After November 16, that window closes and the fines from the interim period will be treated as final, pending whatever the judge decides.
If you have one of these letters tucked away in a drawer, today is the day to pull it out, check the date, and act.
Official sources
- DHS/DOJ final rule, «Imposition and Collection of Civil Penalties for Certain Immigration-Related Violations», 91 FR 65390, October 14, 2026 — https://www.federalregister.gov/d/2026-21024
- DHS ratification notice, «Ratification of Civil Penalties», 91 FR 67325, October 26, 2026 — https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/10/26/2026-21751/ratification-of-civil-penalties
- La Nación, «El DHS es claro: la norma definitiva sobre el cobro de multas por faltas relacionadas con la inmigración», November 15, 2026 — https://www.lanacion.com.ar/estados-unidos/migraciones/el-dhs-es-claro-la-norma-definitiva-sobre-el-cobro-de-multas-por-faltas-relacionadas-con-la-nid15112026/
- Immigration Analytics, «ICE Civil Fines: DHS Rule Challenged as Defying Court Stay», November 6, 2026 — https://immigration-analytics.com/2026/11/06/ice-civil-fines-court-stay/
- Immigration Analytics, «Failure to Depart Fines: DHS Ratifies Past Penalties», October 25, 2026 — https://immigration-analytics.com/2026/10/25/failure-to-depart-fines-ratification/




Comentarios