
22%. That is the number that will haunt the new Senate for the next six years.
It is not a proposal. It is not a campaign threat. It is what would happen, automatically, if Congress does nothing: when Social Security’s retirement trust fund runs out, in late 2032, the payroll taxes still coming in would only cover 78% of promised benefits. A couple retiring around then would lose about $16,900 a year, according to the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget. And here is the thing to keep in mind: the program would not disappear. The checks would keep coming. They would just come up short.
On Tuesday, November 3, voters elected 17 new senators. Democrats flipped seven seats in red states and took control of the chamber. All of them — Democrats and Republicans alike — arrive with the same problem on the table, and a deadline hanging over them: their terms run until January 2033. The fund runs out a few months earlier.
What the official numbers say
The Social Security Trustees’ 2026 report, published by the Social Security Administration itself, leaves little room for optimism. The Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) fund will be able to pay 100% of scheduled benefits until the fourth quarter of 2032, one quarter earlier than projected last year. After that, continuing income would cover 78%.
There is a nuance worth understanding, because headlines mix it up. The combined fund — retirement plus disability — would last until the third quarter of 2034, with 83% payable. But that assumes Congress authorizes moving money between the two funds, something current law does not allow. The disability fund, for its part, is healthy: it would pay 100% at least through the year 2100. The hole is in retirement, and it is dated 2032.
The 75-year actuarial deficit is 4.42% of taxable payroll, worse than the 3.82% in the previous report. Behind the deterioration, according to the report itself, are fewer births and less immigration than expected.
Why 51 votes will not be enough this time
Fixing Social Security cannot be done through budget reconciliation, the shortcut that lets laws pass with a simple majority. It will take 60 votes. In other words: a bipartisan deal, or nothing.
Nearly all the new senators talked about the issue during their campaigns. What changes is what each of them means by “protecting” the program. Fortune gathered this Saturday, November 7, what each one has actually said, and the map looks like this.
The idea that comes up most: taxing the highest earners
Today, Social Security taxes apply only to the first $184,500 of a worker’s yearly earnings. Everything earned above that figure does not pay a cent to the program. Several of the new senators want to change that, and it is the proposal with the most support among the newcomers.
Juliana Stratton, Democrat from Illinois, said she would eliminate the cap entirely. Josh Turek, from Iowa, would also raise it, and opposes raising the retirement age. Troy Jackson, from Maine, put it plainly in a September op-ed: scrap the cap, raise benefits, and no privatization and no raising the age. Abdul El-Sayed, from Michigan, wants to remove the cap and stop taxing benefits. James Talarico, from Texas, proposes eliminating the cap for people earning over $400,000. Adam Hamilton, from Kansas, is more moderate: raise the cap, not eliminate it — someone earning a million dollars, he argues, should not pay the same as someone earning $184,500.
The SSA’s own actuaries calculated that eliminating the cap starting in 2027, without raising benefits for those extra earnings, would close about 58% of the projected 75-year shortfall. It does not solve everything. But it is more than half.
Peggy Flanagan, from Minnesota, backs the most ambitious legislative route: she supports Senator Bernie Sanders’ Social Security Expansion Act, which would apply payroll taxes to wages above $250,000, eventually eliminate the cap, and raise benefits.
The other side: stop taxing benefits
On the other side of the debate, several new senators — from both parties — promised to eliminate federal taxes on Social Security benefits. Barry Moore, Republican from Alabama, was an original cosponsor of the Senior Citizens Tax Elimination Act, introduced in February 2025, which would remove benefits from taxable income and replace the money with general funds. Harriet Hageman, Republican from Wyoming, cosponsored it too. Annie Andrews, Democrat from South Carolina, supports the same idea.
It sounds good. The fine print is another story: eliminating taxes on benefits without replacing the revenue would cost Social Security about $1 trillion over ten years, plus another $700 billion for Medicare, according to a July analysis by the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget. In other words, a popular promise that, on its own, makes the hole it claims to plug even bigger.
Those who have not put numbers on the table
Not everyone arrived with a plan. Andy Barr, Republican from Kentucky, opposed changes for people already retired and called for bipartisan reforms for younger generations, without naming specific taxes or benefit changes, though he talked about encouraging more private and employer-sponsored retirement savings. Roy Cooper, from North Carolina, made the 2032 deadline a staple of his campaign: he opposes benefit cuts and says wealthy Americans should contribute more, without specifying how. Kurt Alme, Republican from Montana, proposes that savings from cutting “waste, fraud, and abuse” elsewhere in government go toward Social Security; in an October debate he cited his experience as Montana’s budget director, but did not propose changes to the cap or the benefit formula. Chris Pappas, from New Hampshire, opposes raising the retirement age, cutting benefits, and privatization, and highlights his cosponsorship of the 2025 Social Security Fairness Act, which boosted benefits for public workers with outside pensions.
What to do today, in order
First, check your statement. Go to ssa.gov, open your my Social Security account, and look at your estimates at ages 62, 67, and 70. It is free, it takes minutes, and it is the only number that matters for your case. Also check the Social Security payment calendar.
Second, do not make decisions out of panic. The 22% cut is a projection if nothing changes, not a law that has passed. And Congress has acted before: the last major reform was in 1983, when the program was in a similar situation. Keep in mind: a work permit and 40 credits do not guarantee retirement.
Third, follow the debate starting in January, when the new Congress takes office. The proposals that matter — the $184,500 cap, taxes on benefits, the retirement age — will be voted on there, with 60 votes or no fix at all. What gets decided in the next two years will define how much you collect. And check what changes for your 2027 taxes.
The fund has a date. The senators do, too.
Official sources
- Social Security Administration, Summary of the 2026 Trustees Reports: https://www.ssa.gov/oact/TRSUM/
- Fortune, “A new group of senators from both parties will vote on how to save Social Security. Here’s what they’ve said about it” (November 7, 2026): https://dnyuz.com/2026/11/07/a-new-group-of-senators-from-both-parties-will-vote-on-how-to-save-social-security-heres-what-theyve-said-about-it/
- Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget: https://www.crfb.org/




Comentarios