
“It goes without saying that just because someone is Latino does not mean that the person is in the United States illegally.”
That sentence, from federal Judge Maame Ewusi-Mensah Frimpong, sits at the heart of an 84-page order made public this Thursday, October 29, in Los Angeles. It is not a general statement about immigration. It is a preliminary court order — a temporary measure, not a final ruling — that sets a concrete limit on how federal agents may stop people in seven Southern California counties.
What does it ban, exactly? The government continuing, as the order puts it, a practice of detentive stops based on racial stereotyping in the Central District of California. That covers ICE and Border Patrol agents. The ban has a narrow exception: it does not apply at a port of entry, a checkpoint, or another functional equivalent of the border.
And there is a rule worth reading in full, because the fine print is where it lives. To decide whether reasonable suspicion exists, an agent must look at the totality of the circumstances. The agent may not rely solely on a person appearing, in the agent’s judgment, Latino and low-income or working-class. Not even if that impression were right. Appearance alone is not enough.
The order covers the Central District: Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside, San Bernardino, San Luis Obispo, Santa Barbara and Ventura. Outside those counties, it does not apply. It does not stop all immigration enforcement either: a stop with reasonable suspicion, built on more than appearance, is still possible. The court also partly certified a class of people affected by the practice, which lets the case move forward with more plaintiffs inside the same proceeding.
The case did not start yesterday. It is called Vasquez Perdomo v. Mullin and began in July 2025, after an incident on June 18 of that year in Pasadena: three men were waiting for a bus near a Winchell’s Donuts shop, at six in the morning, on their way to help rebuild Altadena, when federal agents surrounded and detained them. The lawsuit was brought by the ACLU of Southern California and other organizations — including the National Day Laborer Organizing Network, United Farm Workers and CHIRLA — and, according to the court, the evidence gathered over more than a year includes body-camera video, agents’ depositions and testimony from day laborers, car wash workers, street vendors and farmworkers detained since June 2025.
Watch this, because the history matters. In July 2025 the same judge had already blocked stops of this kind with a temporary order. In September 2025, the Supreme Court stayed that order while the litigation went on — in Noem v. Vasquez Perdomo — and the challenged practices were able to continue. This new order, issued on October 23 and kept under seal until it became public on the 29th, is another chapter, not the end: it is preliminary, the government disputes it on the merits and, according to reports, already filed a notice of appeal to the Ninth Circuit on October 28. In other words, the story can still change hands on appeal.
The Department of Homeland Security has repeatedly denied that its operations are based on race and maintains that agents act under the law and on fact-based investigations. That is its position, and it is on the record. The order also arrives at a moment of aggressive enforcement: DHS counted this same week the tally of 2.2 million USCIS actions to take away status since January 2025. On the other side, the plaintiffs say they will monitor compliance street by street. Flor Melendrez, executive director of the CLEAN Carwash Worker Center and a plaintiff in the case, put it this way: the law requires more than a guess about a person’s situation, and today the court made the government follow it.
The timing is no accident either. The order became known five days before the November 3 elections, with mail voting already underway in California. It decides no election, but it lands in the middle of that fight: this same week another federal judge refused to set aside more than 20,000 ballots in the state.
So what changes today for someone living in Southern California? The order grants no immigration status and erases no pending case. What it does is set a standard an agent must be able to explain: if you are stopped, the reason cannot be only how you look. If that happens to you, keep the date, the place, the time and everything you remember about what was said, and talk to an immigration lawyer before signing any document. And do not pay anyone selling the order as if it were a permit: it is not. It is a procedural protection, in seven counties, while the case runs its course — with the appeal already on its way.
Official sources
- ACLU of Southern California, press release of October 29, 2026 (primary source; links to the order): https://www.aclusocal.org/press-releases/federal-court-blocks-unlawful-suspicionless-racially-discriminatory-immigration-stops-in-southern-california/
- Judge Frimpong’s order, ECF 823 (PDF, 84 pages, Vasquez Perdomo v. Mullin): https://www.aclusocal.org/app/uploads/2026/10/ECF-823-Order-Granting-Suspicionless-Stops-PI.pdf
- EFE, October 29, 2026 (via Swissinfo): https://www.swissinfo.ch/spa/juez-de-california-prohíbe-que-agentes-migratorios-interroguen-a-gente-con-base-en-su-raza/92298794
- Bloomberg Law, October 29, 2026 (judge’s quote and order made public Thursday): https://news.bloomberglaw.com/litigation/agents-barred-from-racial-stereotyping-stops-in-la-judge-rules




Comentarios