First-generation college graduate wearing a black cap decorated with flowers and the words First Gen 24 at a graduation ceremony.
Photo: Zion Smith / Pexels.

“If we wanna have an immigration reform to where we can look at DACA and figure out a way that these individuals can become maybe legal permanent citizens or something like this, that’ll be up to Congress to do that.”

That was Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin on Monday. It is the first time the official in charge of ICE, Border Patrol and USCIS has spoken publicly about a path to permanent residence for Dreamers. And he said it with the brake on in the same sentence: that is Congress’s call, not his. Amnesty, never.

The remark came a day after Trump told 60 Minutes that his deportation campaign “might be too tough” and opened the door to a deal. On Monday, the president narrowed it: there will be no amnesty, and his policy has not changed. Between the two statements sits a narrow opening — and 455,200 people watching it.

What Mullin said, and where he said it

Mullin spoke to reporters on the sidelines of a counter-drone conference in Forest Heights, Maryland, on Monday, November 9. He said that since the midterms he has been fielding calls from Democrats he worked with in Congress, interested in legislating with the new Congress. And Trump gave him the green light to start talking with them.

“I’ve let the president know that those calls are coming in. And the president has said, you know, let’s start working with them and then let’s meet at some point. So that’s the extent of the conversation,” Mullin said, according to the AP. “We haven’t had any conversation just on policy.”

Watch this closely: there is no proposal, no bill, no date. What exists is an authorized conversation to begin. Mullin was a senator and a representative before joining the Department of Homeland Security this year, and he said he worked on immigration reform in both chambers: he believes the only way to get anything done is a bipartisan approach.

There is one fact pulling in the other direction. Trump has just elevated Stephen Miller — the architect of the hard-line policy — to White House chief of staff. Mullin called him on social media “an excellent choice.” Any negotiation with Democrats will go through that door.

The brake came in the same sentence

Mullin left no room for interpretation about the word that makes the most noise in this debate:

“I was working on immigration reform when I was in the House and when I was in the Senate. I think the only way you can actually get it is by a bipartisan approach. But amnesty’s never going to be a solution. We’re never gonna allow amnesty to happen. So that’s a full stop.”

Hours later, Trump said the same thing from the White House, in an unscheduled appearance in the James S. Brady Press Briefing Room: “There won’t be amnesty.” His deportation policy is “very strong,” it has not changed, and enforcement stays focused on what he called “the worst of the worst”: killers and drug dealers.

The president also acknowledged something he rarely says in public: that many immigrants without papers hold good jobs and pay taxes, and that he is working with various groups on a solution that does not involve amnesty. But he offered no bill, no eligibility rules, no timeline. And asked whether he had told Miller to change deportation policy after the 60 Minutes interview, he said he had not discussed changes with him.

Enforcement, meanwhile, is not moving. The White House confirmed that ICE’s target is rising to 2,700 arrests a day, and both Trump and Mullin repeated that the enforcement approach is not changing.

455,200 people, and 81% were born in Mexico

The number sets the scale: about 455,200 people held active DACA status at the end of March 2026, according to USAFacts, which compiles USCIS data. Roughly 81 percent were born in Mexico. California holds the largest population, about 126,910 people, followed by Texas, with about 76,050.

It is worth remembering what DACA is — and what it is not. It is deferred action, a decision not to pursue removal, for two years, renewable, with a work permit. It is not lawful status: USCIS says so on its own official page, “deferred action does not provide lawful status.” Renewals are still being processed, but initial requests are accepted and not processed under a court injunction in place since 2021, affirmed by the Fifth Circuit in January 2025.

Mullin’s phrase also blends two different things: “legal permanent citizens” is not one status. Permanent residence — the green card — comes first; citizenship comes later, through naturalization, usually after five years. And the path is not automatic: immigration law, in Section 245(a), only lets a person adjust status inside the country if they were inspected and admitted or paroled. Most DACA recipients entered without inspection, so almost none has that route today, except those who traveled on advance parole and returned, and also have a qualifying family or employment petition behind them. Only an act of Congress can change that.

Which bills are on the table (and none is law)

The closest model is the American Dream and Promise Act, which the House passed in 2019 and again in 2021 without ever reaching a Senate vote. House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries named it on Monday on CBS as a starting point, alongside restoring DACA and TPS protections. On the other side, the House Freedom Caucus has already posted on X that it rejects amnesty.

Another proposal is making the rounds: the Dignity Act (H.R. 4393), bipartisan, which would grant renewable work status — not a green card — in exchange for a $7,000 restitution payment, back taxes and periodic check-ins. Its supporters say that is not amnesty; some Republican critics say it is.

The math helps no one. The new Congress, with Democratic majorities in both chambers according to reports, convenes on January 3, 2027. But most legislation still needs 60 votes in the Senate, plus the president’s signature. And an AP voter poll cited on Monday found about six in ten voters believe enforcement has gone too far. That is the pressure keeping the door ajar.

What to do today, and what not to pay for

Nothing changes today. There is no new program to sign up for, no form, no list, no fee. Anyone charging you to sign up for a “DACA green card” or an “amnesty” that does not exist yet is selling smoke — or worse, a scam. The same goes for the Dignity Act: it is pending, not law, and nobody can charge you for a benefit that does not exist.

What still applies is the usual advice, and right now it matters more than ever: renew on time. DACA protection lasts only as long as each two-year grant. If your permit is about to expire, check the date and renew early; if you have a pending case or questions about your situation, talk to a licensed immigration attorney before paying anyone.

This is not legal advice. It is what is known this Tuesday morning: the Homeland Security chief opened a door that had been shut for years, the president drew the line in the same sentence, and Congress — which convenes in January — has the final word.

Official sources

Sources and verification

Check the corresponding official sites to confirm current requirements:

Last update of this article: .

Informational content, not tax, legal, or financial advice. Always consult official sources. Informational content, not tax, legal, or financial advice. Always consult official sources.

Comentarios

Leave a Reply

No compartas datos personales sensibles (SSN, ITIN, números de cuenta) en los comentarios.