Packed groceries and canned food ready for donation, including pasta, water bottles, and bread
Photo: Julia M Cameron / Pexels

Two days left.

Sunday, November 1, is the date 42 million people have marked on the fridge, on the phone, or in their heads. That day, under the order the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) sent states on October 24, no new SNAP benefit would be loaded. And now, 48 hours before that Sunday, the fight is no longer only in Congress. It is in two courtrooms.

One thing needs to be clear from the start: even if a judge sides with the plaintiffs, that does not mean the money shows up on the card on Sunday. That is the part causing the most confusion, and it is worth separating right away.

What happened Thursday in Boston

On Thursday, October 29, federal Judge Indira Talwani heard in Boston the case brought by 25 states and the District of Columbia. The lawsuit, which we covered here, asks USDA to use its contingency fund to pay November instead of suspending everything.

The judge did not mince words with the government’s lawyers. She reminded them that Congress put money in an emergency fund precisely for an emergency, and that it is hard to understand how this is not one. The line, spoken in open court, sums up the problem better than any press release: if there is a fund for emergencies, what clearer emergency is there than 42 million people without their food help?

Talwani also pointed to something the government had not wanted to discuss in public. If the money does not cover the full month, she said, the law provides a process for reducing benefits equitably. Not suspending them all at once, just like that. And she left another detail that matters more than it seems: even though the case was brought by certain states, a ruling on a federal program like this would, in practice, apply across the whole country.

At the end of the hearing, the judge indicated her decision would come soon. Soon, in this case, means hours or days. Not weeks.

The second front: today, in Rhode Island

Meanwhile, in Providence, Rhode Island, there is a second case. It was brought by cities, nonprofits, and community groups, and its hearing before federal Judge John J. McConnell was scheduled for this Friday, October 30.

The argument is similar, but the plaintiffs are not the same. Here they are not governors: they are city halls and organizations that serve, every day, the people lining up at food banks. They are asking the court to order USDA to use the contingency funds so November payments are made as soon as possible.

Two courts, two different cases, one same question: can the government say it has no way to pay when it has billions set aside for emergencies?

The disputed fund, in numbers

SNAP costs around $8 billion a month and serves about 42 million people, roughly one in eight in the United States. The contingency fund at the center of the fight is around $5 billion, according to figures used by USDA itself and the press covering the case; some estimates put it at about $5.3 billion.

Do the math and you will see why the debate is not just yes or no. Even using the whole fund, it would not cover the full month. That is why the judges are giving the parties a choice between two paths: pay part of it with the contingency fund, or pay the full month by also finding other available funds. That difference — partial or full — is what millions of households are waiting to see decided.

The government, for its part, argues that money cannot legally be used during a shutdown because the appropriation for regular benefits no longer exists, and that it is reserved for disasters and other emergencies. Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins said it on television plainly: without the government open, they cannot move the money. The suing states reply that USDA’s own original plan, before the shutdown, contemplated using that fund to keep SNAP running.

Even if the plaintiffs win, November 1 does not fix itself

Here is the fine print, and it matters.

Loading EBT cards is not pressing a button. Each state has its own schedule and its own system, and loading millions of cards takes days in many states, and more than a week in some. That means that, even with a favorable ruling this weekend, it is very likely that on Sunday, November 1, many cards will still show no deposit, and that the money — full or partial — will arrive later, on different days depending on the state.

Nobody should do the month’s big grocery shop counting on everything being settled by Sunday.

What to do today, in order

First, check your state SNAP agency’s notice and your EBT card balance before you go shopping. The states are the ones loading the cards, and each one is communicating something different.

Second, find the food bank nearest your county right now. Do not wait until Sunday to look for it: food banks have been serving more people since the suspension was announced, and demand rises every day.

Third, keep any letter or message from your state about November. If the payment arrives partial or late, that notice is your record of what you were told and when.

And fourth, do not mix this up with other SNAP changes already underway. Here we explained the October 24 suspension order; here the lawsuit by the 25 states; here the Arizona case, which lost almost half its benefits under a different law. They are three different blows, and it is best not to confuse them.

What happens between today and Monday — when the judges expect answers from the government — will define whether November gets paid, how much gets paid, and when it arrives. We will update this piece as soon as there is a ruling.

Official sources

Sources and verification

Check the corresponding official sites to confirm current requirements:

Last update of this article: .

Informational content, not tax, legal, or financial advice. Always consult official sources. Informational content, not tax, legal, or financial advice. Always consult official sources.

Comentarios

Leave a Reply

No compartas datos personales sensibles (SSN, ITIN, números de cuenta) en los comentarios.