A person drops a ballot into a voting box
Foto de Sora Shimazaki en Pexels

“It would wreak havoc.”

That, without hedging, is how federal Judge David O. Carter described what would happen if California had to separate, five days before the midterm elections, the mail ballots of more than 20,000 voters. On Wednesday, October 28, he denied the temporary order the Justice Department had asked for. The ballots are processed and counted as always. Full stop.

The ruling came a day after Tuesday’s hearing in Los Angeles, the same hearing where Carter had already made clear he doubted the plan — we covered it here, when the judge promised to rule on Wednesday — and where he told the federal government that if it believed someone had voted without being a citizen, the way forward was to indict them. Not to quietly set their ballot aside.

What the Department asked for, and what the judge denied

The Justice Department sued California on October 15, with early voting already underway. It said the state had missed a 48-hour deadline to review a list of 20,000 names that, according to federal agencies, were likely noncitizens on the voter rolls. It sought a temporary restraining order: those mail ballots would be set aside, uncounted, until each person’s immigration status could be verified.

Carter said no. And it was not a soft no.

In his decision he wrote that never before, in the country’s history, had the federal government tried, on the eve of an election, to force a state and local government to abandon its own constitutional procedures and bend to the will of the Executive Branch. “Constitutional rights and our democracy are at stake. The public interest favors their protection,” he added, as reported by AFP. And he drove home the central point: people who met California’s registration requirements “must not be deprived of a core right merely because of unfounded allegations stemming from a procedure rife with uncertainty and errors.”

One detail carries weight. The Department never said how many of those 20,000 people had already submitted a mail ballot. Nor did it convince the judge that its list was reliable: California called it “suspect data” and warned that complying risked leaving eligible citizens without a vote. Carter also warned the measure would have a chilling effect on voters and election workers alike.

Watch this: what was denied was the temporary order, the emergency measure. It is not the last word on the merits of the case, and the Department can appeal. But for this election, with more than 3.7 million Californians having already voted, according to AP, the count does not stop or split in two.

The list, from 190,000 down to 20,000

The number shrank on its own. For months, the federal government accused California of having 190,000 illegal voters on its books. Then it revised the figure to 20,000 and filed the emergency lawsuit about ten days before the ruling, after voting had already begun.

Something similar happened in Nevada, and AFP recalled it while covering the ruling: there the administration first identified 16,000 supposed noncitizen voters; after verification, the number fell to 185 and then to zero.

The Monday before, an appeals court had already closed another door to the Department: it rejected its emergency request to block the count in California before Carter could rule. It is the same pattern seen this week in the Ninth Circuit, which also refused to block California’s votes and has the 400-name Washington list in front of it.

Beyond California, the Department also intervened in two other states with competitive races, Reuters reported. In Alaska it asked a judge to prevent certification if the Republican incumbent senator loses narrowly, because a candidate with a similar name is on the ballot; Alaska asked for the case to be dismissed. In Washington, on Monday, it sent a letter asking officials not to count ballots from 400 voters it said may not be citizens. That state’s top elections official said the timing of the request seemed designed to cast unfounded suspicion on the results.

Nobody in this fight disputes the basics: voting in federal elections without being a citizen is illegal. What is in dispute is something else: whether a list built from data the judge himself found unreliable is enough to halt the counting of thousands of ballots days before an election. Studies and state audits, Reuters notes, show again and again that noncitizen voting is rare.

What to do if you vote in California

Nothing different from what you were going to do. If you already voted by mail, your ballot follows its normal course. If you have not voted yet, vote as you had planned: by mail, at an official drop box, or in person. The election is Tuesday, November 3, and California has 52 House seats at stake, more than any other state, plus 23 million registered voters.

Unsure about your registration? Check it through your state’s official channel or at Vote.gov, which takes you to the right site — the November 3 election guide brings the steps and dates together. And if you get a message saying your ballot was set aside, will not be counted, or that there is a new list, do not share it without checking: in a week like this, the rumor travels faster than the ruling.

Official sources

Reuters, “US Justice Dept loses initial bid to block votes from alleged noncitizens in California”, October 29, 2026: https://www.reuters.com/world/us-justice-dept-loses-initial-bid-block-votes-alleged-noncitizens-california-2026-10-29/ — AP, via La Nación, “Judge denies federal request to segregate California ballots, says it would ‘wreak havoc’ on voting”, October 29, 2026: https://www.lanacion.com.ar/usa/judge-denies-federal-request-to-segregate-california-ballots-says-it-would-wreak-havoc-on-voting-nid28102026/ — AFP, via The New Indian Express, “US judge rejects Trump admin interference in California midterm vote”, October 29, 2026: https://www.newindianexpress.com/world/2026/Oct/29/us-judge-rejects-trump-admin-interference-in-california-midterm-vote — Vote.gov (official portal to check registration and rules by state): https://vote.gov

Sources and verification

Check the corresponding official sites to confirm current requirements:

Last update of this article: .

Informational content, not tax, legal, or financial advice. Always consult official sources. Informational content, not tax, legal, or financial advice. Always consult official sources.

Comentarios

Leave a Reply

No compartas datos personales sensibles (SSN, ITIN, números de cuenta) en los comentarios.